New York Real Estate Market Finally Crashing

|

newyorkskyline.jpgIt took a while. But now, with Wall Street's help, it's finally happening:

Post: Toll Brothers, the largest US luxury homebuilder, said fourth-quarter revenue plunged 41 percent as the housing and credit crisis pummeled its business.

The builder is also seeing housing demand in New York City, which had been a "beacon," slumping in the past six weeks, CEO Robert Toll said.

"It has now joined the ranks of the rest of the country," Toll said.

The "rest of the country" is now down 21% from the peak, with Vegas leading the way (down 39%). The country is on track to bottom down about 40%. New York was a bit more bubbly than average, but less so than Vegas. So it will be interesting to see how far New York falls.

See Also: Robert Shiller: New York Real Estate Market to Crash, Too



< Prev. Story
Next Story >

18 Comments

Jack said:
FINALLY! This marks the beginning of the end...NY area real estate still has a long way to go down.
Jocko said:
Ah the heart of the debt bubble was created in NYC by NYC people. These scum merchants will get it worse in their local real-estate then the rest of us.
Andy NYC said:
Disagree. You guys do not understand the basis of economy not to mention Real Estate.

In general real estate in NYC always falls less than the rest of the country. On top of that, Real Estate in NYC is the last one to fall. There won't be no 40% drop. If there is a 40% drop in NYC you can be sure to see 75% drop everywhere else.

Now open go to Amazon, buy few books and figure out why I wrote the above statement. I'm not helping you any further. Stop listening to those economic exports, you are going to go broke.
john haskell said:
The only news here is that NYC held out so long. Because of the tight restrictions on supply and the widespread religious belief that the East and Hudson Rivers somehow form a moat that protects Manhattan from nationwide economic trends, Manhattan was able to hold out longer than other areas.

But the economic reality is that NYC is a levered play on US GDP. It is not a play on jet-lagged Europeans flying eight hours to buy condos with newly depreciated euros, it is not a play on "everybody wants to live here," it is a play on the second derivative of changes in US GDP.
Joseph di Jersey City said:
Andy NYC: Do you remember the last time there was a bear market resembling today's? In case not, it was the early '70s. You may want to temper your arrogance and boosterism by considering what the NYC housing market (and quality of life in general) was like in the late '70s.
Andy, would love to hear more. I've read quite a bit about the NY real estate market. If you can give us a snapshot of why we're so wrong, I'd be grateful.
Sebastian said:
I agree with Andy. If the real estate market drops 40% in NYC, you will have a ton of int. investors (private and institutional) buying real estate all over the city.
Kid Dynamite (URL) said:
i agree with andy, and there are a number of reasons, although i admit this is all qualitative, not quantitative:

1) the average buyer of a $1.5MM co-op in NYC didn't have a 100% interest only NINJA loan that their getting "surprised" on now like the rest of ignorant america. The co-op system is somewhat self regulating in that sense.

2) the chooches who levered themselves to the max and would have to sell at their first missed bonus were the mortgage brokers who lived in Jersey and Long Island. (sorry, but it's true)

3) there are plenty of wall street guys levered up, but i don't think they puke their apartment after one year of missed bonuses. I'd guess, that most owners, even if bonuses are down 75% or more, would still be able to hang on another year

4) thus, it will take a full EXTRA year or two of a diasterous economy (which we may very well get) before we see the decline in NYC that we saw elsewhere

5) they aren't building anymore townhouses in the Village - so areas like that don't lose value. they DID, however, throw up a 35 story high rise on every corner of sixth avenue from 18th st to 26th street - these can certainly take a dump.
-KD
PublicAcct655321 said:
Perhaps no one has noticed all the buidlings being thrown up in brooklyn. The same buidlings that are vacant, or not even complete. I'm not saying the market for RE in NY isn't coming down, I'm just saying there is def surplus. We'd be remiss to think otherwise.
lx150+ said:
To better get a grip on what's going on in Manhattan (not ANY of the outer boroughs), you first need to seperate the 4 forms of housing

Rental

Condo

Co-Op

Townhouses

Will the market be down, sure, but more so in the first two than the second two, and even then not by much. Anyone with a Co-op or townhouse is secure, job or not, market at 9000 or 6000. It's that hard to get into a Co-op and to even think there is such a thing as an affordable townhouse in this city is maddening.

As far as condos, appox 1 in 3 is owned by a foreigner, due to the ease of buying one.

What you're seeing in the condo/ rental market is condos that were built to be sold are now renting units that weren't sold, creating more rental units. Rental buildings in good areas will continue to hold value as the people who live in them likely have no alternative.

Plus, you have MANY building owners in the city who own their buildings for literally nothing, so they can afford to cut their prices on rentals and still make a kiling. You are beginning to see this in both residential and commercial. They can afford to bring the market down x% because they will still do well, and thus put the squeeze on the levered spec condos that were built along the west side and in less desirable areas.


ga2vidao (URL) said:
Welcome to Louis Vuitton Store! We are proud to carry a wide variety of Louis Vuitton Bags. Louis Vuitton has affirmed itself over the past decades as a world leading brand name in the fashion industry.
LV handbags
Holding an Louis Vuitton bags makes you the center of attention in any occasion. For a lady especially, Louis Vuitton has been a legendary brand, with magic embodiment, representing a dream handbag of fashion.
hober1167 said:
Prices are going to come way down...all this talk about NYC being insulated is garbage. Yes, long term, MANHATTAN will rebound and go up, but the boroughs are pretty screwed.

And just wait until RE taxes jump by 500%...all these deficits the state and city are talking about...where do you think they're going to make up the difference? Does anyone really believe that that will help RE prices remain high?

Or how about all the city services that are going to be cut? Wait until the crime rate spikes...it's already starting to happen.

I'm not saying armegeddon is coming, but it's going to get very ugly before it gets better.
davido (URL) said:
I couldn't happen to a shittier bunch o' opportunistic jerks. Let's see, they posted sensationalist headlines Tiffany jewellery and stories that hurt the guilty and innocent alike, repeatedly picked on people who weren't remotely public figures, and basically reveled in others' misfortunes.
davido3 (URL) said:
I will break it down for you so you understand:
1) Do not "hand over" your inventory to ad networks, give them your unsold inventory. Keep your sales team in place. CNN uses Advertising.com to sell their unsold inventory for example.
2) There are enough ad networks out there fighting to represent premium sites with unsold inventory - Gawker has good content. CPM rates might lower in the long run,Online shopping but getting paid for something is better than nothing - it's as simple as that.
3) As for video, who says Gawker needs to create their own? YouTube certainly doesn't. They can grab videos out there and run ads Online collector against them. Maybe have user video reviews or something on Gizmodo for example...just an idea.
4)TV never gave into the third party route?
外国為替 (URL) said:
FX, foreign exchange trading(外国為替)would begin, the New Tokyo foreign exchange market in the city's securities. Get information about the latest FX low-risk trading FX! Free trade foreign exchange in the virtual experience.
インプラント (URL) said:
Hachioji Implant Center, インプラントspecializing in the treatment of implant treatment of the environment for full, yet experienced dental implant the country boasts one of the best dental office experience and success.
fdg said:
DVD burner for Mac provides an easy and fast way to convert popular video formats (including AVI, MPEG, WMV, DivX, XviD, MP4, DV, VOB, ASF, 3GP, NUT, YUV, H.264/AVC, M4V files to DVD. The DVD Burner Mac could also burn DVD movie onto DVD disk that playable on portable or home DVD player and burn DVD folder or ISO files. No other Mac DVD burner can provide so many formats.
DivX to DVD Converter for Mac can not only convert DivX to DVD Mac, but also support convert AVI to DVD, 3GP to DVD, MP4 to DVD, FLV to DVD, MPEG to DVD, WMV to DVD, etc.
The DivX to DVD Converter Mac developed only for Mac OS (include Mac OS X 10.5 leopard) burning users.
The DivX to DVD converter for Mac can convert all formats like MP4, M4V, MPA, MPG, MPEG, MOV,3GP, 3GP2, FLV, MOV,VOB, DAT, TS, TP, TRP, M2TS, DivX, DivX to DVD on Mac OS.
AVI to DVD for Mac, a profeesional but easy-to-use DVD burn software for Mac users, can convert AVI to DVD format on Mac OS X perfectly and quickly. The AVI to DVD Mac not only supports converting AVI to DVD Mac but also supports other popular formats to DVD on Mac, such as MPA, ASF, DIF, H261, YUV, NUT and so on.
With the AVI to DVD Mac, you can easily convert and burn AVI files to your DVD and play it on portable or home DVD player.
DVD Converter Mac is a powerful DVD converter for Mac OS users to rip DVD to all popular video and audio formats with various customized settings and convert video among all popular video and audio formats with perfect 1:1 ratio on Mac. In fact, the DVD Converter Mac is a DVD Converter for Mac Ultimate which includes 4 outstanding multimedia applications: DVD Ripping Mac, DVD Creater for Mac, Copy DVD on Mac and Mac Video Converter.With the DVD Converter Mac, you can convert MP4, M4V, MPA, MPG, MPEG, MOV, 3GP, 3GP2, FLV, VOB, DAT, TS, TP, TRP, M2TS, AVI to DVD and even burn DVD movie on Mac.That's sure powerfully, hurry to see it!DVD Converter for Mac.Now let's see another converter software is Mac AVI Converters.Mac AVI Converters is a powerful and versatile Video/Audio Conversion utility for Mac OS X users to convert video files from one format to another and extract or save the audio tracks on Mac OS X (including OS X 10.5 Leopard). The Mac AVI Converters helps you convert AVI to video formats like, DivX, MPEG, MPG, FLV, DAT, MOV, ASF, FLV, etc. It can also extract audio from video to MP3, WMA, AC3, AAC, M4A, WAV, OGG, 3GP, etc.The Mac AVI Converters can also convert MPEG1, MPEG2, MP4, 3GP, 3G2, MOV, Mpeg TS/TP (for HD Video) formats, too.With such powerful and versatile AVI converter for Mac, you can easily playback AVI video files on any popular video players, like iPod, PSP, Apple TV, Archos, iRiver, Creative Zen, PS3 or other portable MP4 players. Try Mac AVI Converter for free.That's a turely chance,hurry to see it!AVI Converter for Mac.

Join the discussion